Drew Pomeranz
Alex White
Matt McBride
Joe Gardner
Ubaldo Jimenez
I was sitting at Slim N Chubbies out in Strongsville with Mrs. BurningRiver when the news started to trickle in via twitter. We were drinking beers, watching the Tribe battle the Royals, and waiting for my buddy's band to start playing. At first you heard that White and Pomeranz were both scratched from their starts. Then you started to read the tweets that they were both being shipped to Colorado for Jimenez. STO even broke in a few times to the Colorado game to show that Jimenez was pitching, but the Rockies had their bullpen up in the 1st inning. Something was happening. Twitter these days is an amazing thing. Just as I was starting to explain what was going on to Mrs. BurningRiver, two other guys at the bar read the same reports on their phone and soon everyone was talking about the trade. There was even some humorous dialog between a couple that was behind us.
Semi Attractive 28-30 yr old female Bar Patron:
"Wow the Tribe is going to trade for Ubaldo."
Hipster douche bag boyfriend:
"Ubaldo? What is an Ubaldo?"
Semi Attractive 28-30 yr old female Bar Patron:
"He is a pretty good pitcher for the Rockies. We are giving up two good minor leaguers or something for him."
Hipster douche bag boyfriend:
"Oh. blah blah blah, Man my jeans are way to tight."
Semi Attractive 28-30 yr old female Bar Patron: "Blank stare at Hipster boyfriend.... Well I hope we win tonight."
LOL.
Semi Attractive 28-30 yr old female Bar Patron - 1
Hipster douche bag boyfriend - 0
At first I wasn't happy with the Trade. I even sent out a tweet that I thought it was a bad move for the Tribe. We were giving away our top two pitching prospects for a pitcher who was 6-9 this year with a 4.46 ERA. I know he started the NL All-Star game in 2010 and I know his ERA this year was a bit uncharacteristic, but I wasn't initially sold. I really think Drew Pomeranz has a chance to be something special. Why deal him for a pitcher when we clearly need offensive help? I was torn for the next few hours as I watched the Tribe battle back and beat the Royals on a walk-off HR by LaPorta. As more drinks went down and the band started to play I changed my opinion on the deal at least five times.
On one hand the Tribe finally made a big move at the deadline in which we were not giving away a former All-Star for prospects This is exactly what all Tribe fans have been screaming about since 2007. We took a gamble, trading away some players that MIGHT be good in the majors, and landed a potential ace.
On the other hand is Ubaldo really an ace? Has he been battling injuries this year? Is that the reason his ERA is up? Did we just trade for a guy that is going to go down with an elbow or shoulder injury due to throwing 95-99 mph for the past three + seasons with a quirky delivery?
I just couldn't decide. So I let those thoughts simmer for a few days. Now that they have had the proper time to marinate I'm ready to give my official opinion.
I like the trade for the Tribe and here are three reasons why.
1) We don't have room for Pomeranz, White, Huff, Gomez, McAllister, Masterson, Carrasco, Tomlin in our rotation. The last time a checked, most major league managers use a five man rotation. I just named eight guys that all have the ability to be in our rotation next year. I didn't even mention Carmona. By making this deal your rotation going into 2011 should be Ubaldo, Masterson, Tomlin, Carrasco and either Huff, Gomez or Carmona. Ill take that. Pitching wins championships. The Giants just proved that last year and the 90's Indians teams proved that as well.... unfortunately in their case.
2) We now have a three year window to contend with these young arms. Ubaldo, Masterson, Tomlin, etc are all pretty much locked up for the next three seasons. This is big for a mid-market team that cannot give out 100 million dollar contracts. The front office is now all in to win the division for the next three seasons which means we should see increased free agent spending in the off season and at the trade deadline during this window. Hopefully we can make a run this year and then in the off season add a power hitting rand handed bat via free agency. Given how hard it has been to watch CC, Lee, Victor, and others leave us over the past few seasons this should be a very welcomed change.
3) It gives us the ability to win a playoff series if we were to make the playoffs. Being able to throw Ubaldo, Masterson, and Tomlin to start a series puts us right there with a team like the Angels and probably gives us the advantage over the Yanks, BoSox, Rangers, etc. If we had two being able to throw Masterson and Ubaldo twice in a series on 4 days rest is a big plus.
Sure we might have overpaid a bit, and yes I really do think Pomeranz may be a stud, but the potential rewards are worth the risk. At the end of the day this trade seems to go along with our slogan this year.
What If?
If Ubaldo pitches like he did in 2008 - 2010 for us over the next three seasons then we are winners here. He has the ability to make the ball miss the bat. In 851 career innings Ubaldo averages over 8 Ks per 9 innings. Even in 2011, a supposedly down year, he is at 8.63 Ks per 9 so the ability is there. This trait is hard to find and now we have two guys (Ubaldo and Masterson) that can do it.
So instead of worrying about how good Pomeranz or White MIGHT be I'm going to enjoy watching how good Ubaldo ALREADY is.
#Giddyup #Leggo #ItsTribeTimeNow
No comments:
Post a Comment